Delhi High Court Sets Aside Another Patent Refusal Order under Section 3(b)

Delhi High Court Sets Aside Another Patent Refusal Order under Section 3(b)Section 3(b) of the Patents Act, 1970 excludes inventions whose primary or intended use or commercial exploitation would be contrary to public order or morality, or would cause serious prejudice to human, animal or plant life or health, or to the environment, from patentability. The provision requires examination of the nature and intended use of the claimed invention, especially in technologies involving tobacco, nicotine or aerosol-generating products. A patent application cannot be refused simply on assumptions about the field of technology without examining the claimed invention and supporting the objection with scientific analysis and cogent reasoning.

Close on the heels of the remand of 8 Philip Morris cases that were refused by the Patent Office, the Delhi High Court set aside another refusal of a patent application for “Aerosol-Forming Substrate with Nitrogen-Containing Nucleophilic Compound” in Philip Morris Products S.A. vs Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs [C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 29/2025], decided on September 9, 2026.

The Court found that the respondent Controller passed the refusal order based on reasoning and material not communicated to the appellant during examination, violating the principles of natural justice. The Court also found that the respondent Controller had failed to properly assess the cited prior art and consider several crucial submissions of the appellant relating to inventive step and non-patentability under Sections 3(b) and 3(e) of the Patents Act, 1970.

The Court held that merely because the claimed invention relates to an aerosol-generating substance or device, or the use of tobacco or nicotine, cannot, per se, be a ground to deny grant of a patent under Section 3(b). The Court partially allowed the appeal and set aside the impugned order dated January 24, 2025, remanding the matter to the respondent Controller for fresh consideration.

Factual Matrix

Philip Morris Products S.A. filed Patent Application No. 202217021141 for “Aerosol-Forming Substrate with Nitrogen-Containing Nucleophilic Compound”. The application was refused by the respondent Controller on the grounds of lack of inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja) and non-patentability under Sections 3(b) and 3(e) of the Patents Act, 1970. Aggrieved by the refusal order, Philip Morris preferred an appeal before the Delhi High Court.

Appellant’s Case

The appellant submitted that the respondent Controller relied on three documents in support of the objections raised under Section 3(b) that had not been disclosed to the applicant during the examination, thereby depriving him of an opportunity to rebut them or address arguments on these documents, which violates principles of natural justice. The appellant submitted that cellulose or cellulose derivatives as an alternative to tobacco in an aerosol-generating substrate is known in the prior art, and asserted that it was surprisingly found that aerosol-forming substrates not containing tobacco or those which are substantially free of tobacco may produce an aerosol having a high concentration of aldehydes, particularly formaldehyde and therefore, there was a need for reducing the formation of unwanted aldehydes by heating the substrate without burning.

The appellant claimed that the aerosol-forming substrate of the subject application aims to solve the problems associated with use of non-tobacco substitutes known in the art. Additionally, the presence of disaccharide may enable the release of aerosol-former over a longer and extended period of time, allowing a user to enjoy an aerosol generated from the substrate after having taken more than 6, 7 or 8 puffs. The appellant submitted that another objective of the invention was to provide a mechanism for formation of stable and dense aerosol for a longer period of time.

On Section 2(1)(ja)

The appellant argued that the respondent Controller had reached a conclusion that amended Claims 1-14 lack inventive step as required under Section 2(1)(ja) owing to prior arts D1 (GB1355865 A), D2 (US4195645 A) and D3 (US2018352856 A1) without giving any reason as to why a person skilled in the art would be motivated to combine D1-D3 to reach the present invention. The appellant contended that the respondent Controller was required to establish that the relevant features were disclosed in the cited prior art and that there was sufficient motivation for a person skilled in the art to combine the teachings to arrive at the claimed invention.

On Section 3(e)

On the non-patentability under Section 3(e) of the 1970 Act, the appellant argued that the composition disclosed in claim 1 clearly establishes synergism amongst different components, which results in reduction of formaldehyde and helps in maintaining dense and stable aerosol for a longer period of time even after the 7th or 8th puff. The Appellant contended that the respondent Controller has wrongly concluded that the invention is a mere admixture and lacks synergy. The appellant submitted that the respondent Controller had erred in refusing the application under Section 3(e).

Respondent Controller’s Reply

The respondent Controller maintained that the claimed invention’s primary and intended use is contrary to public order and causes serious prejudice to human health. The aerosol-generating device, heating element and heating chamber, according to the respondent Controller, unambiguously constitute an e-cigarette or heat-not-burn device, and the claims and specifications confirm the inclusion of addictive substances, with Claim 8 explicitly claiming nicotine as component ‘f’. The respondent counsel asserted that nicotine is one of the most addictive substances, owing to the rapidity at which it introduces into the body, age of first exposure etc. and the flavours and attractive designs allure the young population and addiction is a disease which affects morality of human beings and the section 3(b) objection is fully supported by the guidelines in the Patent Manual.

The counsel for the respondent submitted that the respondent Controller’s finding that claims 1-14 are obvious is correct, and it is based on a detailed and exhaustive analysis of prior arts D1-D3. The respondent argued that the appellant’s central claim of adding a disaccharide (sucrose) to a cellulosic material (tobacco-free or substantially tobacco-free) for use in an aerosol-generating system is a combination of features which are fully taught and motivated by the cited prior art. The respondent Controller maintained that the refusal to grant the patent on grounds of lack of inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja) and non-patentability under Section 3(b) and (e) of the 1970 Act is justified and supported by reasons.

Court’s Analysis and Findings

On Section 3(b)

The Court found that three crucial documents viz. (a) Report of the Standing Committee of Parliament ‘Review of Intellectual Property Rights Regime in India’ in Rajya Sabha on 23.07.2021 (Annexure-I); (b) Report on ‘Economic Burden of Tobacco Related Diseases in India’ (Annexure-II); and (c) WHO Report on ‘Global Tobacco Epidemic, 2021’ (Annexure-III), were not notified to the Appellant either in the FER or in the hearing notice and were mentioned for the first time in the impugned order and hence, Appellant was deprived of an opportunity to rebut them or address arguments on these documents, which violates principles of natural justice. The Court found that the impugned order reflects that these Reports have weighed heavily with the Respondent in upholding the objection under Section 3(b) and rejecting the submission of the Appellant on this aspect.

The Court found merit in the argument of the appellant that the Legislative intent behind Section 3(b) is to increase the threshold for granting a patent on a claimed invention, which may be intended to cause prejudice or injury to human health and agreed with the appellant that such analysis must be real, with a scientific basis and must come forth from the impugned order. The Court ruled that merely because the claimed invention relates to an aerosol-generating substance or device or use of tobacco or nicotine cannot per se be a ground to deny grant of patent.

The Court observed that the appellant was right in submitting that refusing grant of a patent without appreciating the contribution of the invention and examining how it causes serious prejudice could impede further development in the tobacco industry. The Court also noted the appellant’s submissions that aerosol-forming devices may or may not use tobacco products and that heating, rather than burning, tobacco could contribute to tobacco harm reduction. The Court observed that denying grant of patent merely because an invention involves tobacco or nicotine may not be the correct approach.

On Section 2(1)(ja)

The Court examined the procedure followed by the respondent Controller for determining inventive step in the claimed invention and found that the respondent had not identified the person skilled in the art and had, in fact, adopted a hindsight approach by cherry-picking the components from the tobacco replacement material as taught in D1 and without any technical reasoning as to how and why a person skilled in the art would arrive at the claimed invention, come to a conclusion of obviousness.

The Court observed that in order to prove obviousness, the respondent Controller was required to show that each and every element of claim 1 is disclosed in the prior art and there was motivation for the person skilled in the art to combine various prior art without reasonable expectation of success. The Court ruled that the impugned order is vitiated even on this ground, being contrary to the earlier decisions of the Court in F. Hoffmann; Agriboard; Bristol-Myers and Avery Dennison. The Court also noted that on merits, the respondent Controller has not taken into consideration several relevant and crucial submissions of the Appellant, which, if considered, may have led to a different conclusion.

On Reliance on the Document Not Communicated 

The Court found merit in the argument of the appellant that the respondent Controller’s reliance on the three documents without giving an opportunity to the Appellant to address arguments on them violates principles of natural justice. The Court observed that it is a settled law that no party can be condemned unheard, and if the Respondent intended to rely on these documents, they should have been notified to the Appellant before taking the final decision, to enable the Appellant to deal with them. The Court relied on the ruling of the courts in Otsuka Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd. vs Controller of Patents [2022 SCC OnLine Del 4982], wherein it was held that no person can be condemned unheard and all or any objection on which the respondent wishes to place reliance must be put to the applicant at the stage of issuance of FER/hearing notice.

The Court also relied on Perkinelmer Health Sciences Inc and Others v. Controller of Patents [2023 SCC OnLine Del 8590] wherein it was observed that no new grounds can be taken by the Controller/Examiner at the time of hearing and an applicant must be made aware of all objections before the hearing and afforded sufficient opportunity to contest and in ITC Limited vs The Controller of Patents Designs and Trademark [MANU/WB/1167/2025], the Court held that reliance on the three documents without giving opportunity to the Appellant to address arguments on them, violates principles of natural justice and is fatal.

Court’s Decision

The Court partially allowed the appeal and set aside the impugned refusal order dated January 24, 2025. The matter was remanded to the respondent Controller for fresh consideration of Patent Application No. 202217021141. The Court directed that a decision be taken within five months from September 9, 2026, after granting an opportunity of hearing to the appellant and considering all relevant issues raised.

Conclusion

The Delhi High Court in this case reiterated that denying grant of a patent under Section 3(b) merely because the invention involves tobacco or nicotine may not be the correct approach. The Court held that the mere fact that a claimed invention relates to tobacco, nicotine or an aerosol-generating product does not by itself establish serious prejudice to human health. The respondent Controller is required to carry out an analysis supported by a scientific basis, which must be reflected in the refusal order.

The Court also pointed out that reliance on documents not communicated to the applicant during examination deprives the applicant of an opportunity to deal with the objections forming the basis of refusal. Relying on the decisions in Otsuka, Perkinelmer and ITC Limited, the Court held that such an approach violates the principles of natural justice.

On the determination of inventive step, the Court found that the respondent Controller had not followed the established procedure, including the five-step test referred to in F. Hoffmann. The Controller had failed to properly identify the person skilled in the art and examine the differences between the cited prior art and the claimed invention. The Court also noted that relevant submissions concerning the technical effects of the claimed composition had not been adequately considered.

The Court accordingly partially allowed the appeal and remanded the patent application for fresh consideration. The ruling reinforces that refusal of a patent application must be based on proper examination of the claimed invention, consideration of the applicant’s submissions and a reasoned analysis of the relevant statutory objections.

Author: DPS Parmar (Special Counsel)