Territorial jurisdiction plays an important role in deciding the appropriate forum for dealing with intellectual property disputes. As online commerce and digital platforms expand, identifying where infringement occurs can become complex. Businesses may advertise, offer and sell products in different jurisdictions without having a physical presence in those locations. However, this makes it difficult to identify the extent to which online activities, commercial transactions and the accessibility of websites can establish territorial jurisdiction. Indian courts have addressed these questions through various decisions to balance the protection of IP rights with the rules governing jurisdiction.
Against this backdrop, the Delhi High Court, on November 3, 2026, clarified the principles governing territorial jurisdiction in IP disputes, holding that mere accessibility of websites, isolated online purchases or artificially created transactions cannot, by themselves, establish jurisdiction. In ABD Maestro Private Limited vs Great Galleon Ventures Ltd. and 16 connected commercial suits, the Court examined the circumstances in which courts may entertain actions for trademark and copyright infringement and passing off. The Court emphasised that the growing reach of e-commerce cannot be used to disregard the territorial limits prescribed by law. Applying these principles, the Court directed the return of all seventeen plaints for presentation before courts having appropriate jurisdiction.
Background and Issues Before the Court
The decision came from 17 commercial suits involving disputes across different industries, including alcoholic beverages, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, food products and other goods and services. Although the parties in most cases were located outside Delhi, the plaintiffs had approached the Delhi High Court, claiming territorial jurisdiction based on online accessibility, availability of infringing products, sales through e-commerce platforms and business activities extending to Delhi.
For instance, in ABD Maestro Private Limited vs Great Galleon Ventures Ltd., the plaintiff alleged infringement of its YELLO trademark, label and trade dress through the defendant’s V21 vodka product. The plaintiff relied on the defendant’s GST registration in Delhi, its online presence and commercial activities within the territory. In another suit, Namastu Enterprise Private Limited vs Kajalben Maheshbhai Kaklotar, the plaintiff relied on a test purchase of an infringing product through Amazon, which was delivered to a Delhi address.
The primary question was whether such connections were enough to establish territorial jurisdiction under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, the Trade Marks Act, 1999 and the Copyright Act, 1957. The Court also observed the use of private investigators, the requirements for preventive infringement actions and the application of the doctrine of forum non conveniens.
Under Section 20 of the CPC, a suit may be instituted where the defendant resides or carries on business, or where the cause of action arises wholly or in part. Sections 134(2) of the Trade Marks Act and 62(2) of the Copyright Act provide additional jurisdictional conditions for infringement actions by allowing eligible plaintiffs to file a suit where they reside, carry on business or personally work for gain.
The Court examined the interpretation of “carries on business” in light of the Supreme Court’s decisions in the cases of Patel Roadways, Dhodha House and Indian Performing Rights Society Ltd. vs Sanjay Dalia, along with the Delhi High Court’s decision in Ultra Home Construction case. The Court then clarified that a corporation having a sole office is deemed to carry on business at that location. Where multiple offices exist, the difference between the principal office and subordinate offices becomes important. A corporation may invoke jurisdiction at a subordinate office where the cause of action has also arisen, but cannot bypass that location and file a suit at its principal office if no cause of action has arisen there.
Further, the Court distinguished infringement from passing off, when in a composite suit seeking relief for both, territorial jurisdiction must independently exist for each claim. The existence of jurisdiction for infringement would not automatically allow the court to entertain the passing off claim.
Website Accessibility and Online Transactions
A key part of the decision dealt with jurisdiction from online commercial activities. The Court noted that websites and e-commerce platforms are accessible across India, and goods can often be delivered to virtually any location selected by a purchaser. If accessibility or the possibility of delivery alone established jurisdiction, plaintiffs could institute a suit before almost any court in the country.
Relying on Banyan Tree Holding (P) Ltd. vs A. Murali Krishna Reddy, the Court held that jurisdiction based on website activity requires evidence that the defendant intentionally targeted consumers in the territorial limits of the forum court and caused injury or harm to the plaintiff there. The plaintiff must also show commercial transactions between the defendant and persons located in the forum through the relevant website. Mere advertisements, online listings or the technical ability to place orders are insufficient.
The Court further recognised a limited relaxation of the requirement to show completed commercial transactions when the plaintiff cannot rely on the additional jurisdiction-related provisions under the Trade Marks Act or Copyright Act and the defendant has no presence in India. For offline infringement, the Court noted that a cause of action arises where the defendant uses the impugned mark in the course of business within the forum’s territory. For passing off, the Court highlighted the need to establish commercial sales relating to the defendant within that territory. Mere availability of products through independent traders, without any connection to the defendant’s distribution activities, would not establish jurisdiction.
Regarding Test Purchases and Artificially Created Jurisdiction
The Court kept reservations regarding the practice of engaging investigators or arranging test purchases to establish jurisdiction in a preferred forum. It was observed that a plaintiff or their representative could purchase goods through an online marketplace and select a delivery address anywhere in India. Allowing such a transaction to decide jurisdiction would allow litigants to create their own territorial connections.
However, the Court noted that such evidence may be important where the plaintiff shows that no other court could exercise jurisdiction under Section 20(c) of the CPC, or where existing commercial sales within the forum are independently established, and the investigator merely collects evidence of those activities.
Dynamic Effect of Infringement
The Court also clarified the requirements for quia timet actions, which provide preventive relief against possible infringement. Such an action must be based on a deliberate intention by the defendant to perform an activity that has a strong possibility of infringement. The activity must be imminent and capable of causing substantial prejudice to the plaintiff. For regulated products, the Court held that necessary statutory licences and permissions are needed to assess whether the commercial activity is genuinely imminent.
The Court further rejected reliance on the “dynamic effect” of infringement as an independent ground for territorial jurisdiction. It was noted that allowing jurisdiction simply because the plaintiff experiences the effects of infringement where they have their business would weaken the specific jurisdiction rules in the Trade Marks Act and Copyright Act.
Forum Non Conveniens
One of the most important aspects of the decision is forum non conveniens, under which a court may decline to entertain proceedings in favour of another more appropriate forum. The Court held that this doctrine applies to civil suits. Even where jurisdiction is technically established under the CPC or the IP law, the court may need to examine whether another competent forum has a closer and more considerable connection with the dispute. This requires identifying where the material, integral and essential elements of the cause of action arose. Activities such as manufacturing, packaging, labelling and commercial distribution may have a stronger connection with the dispute than an isolated sale or delivery in another territory.
The Court further clarified that unsupported contentions, internal disagreements and statements designed to create an artificial appearance of jurisdiction would not be accepted merely because they appear in the plaint.
Court’s Decision
Applying this to the 17 suits, the Court found that the plaintiffs had failed to establish sufficient grounds for the Delhi High Court to entertain their suits. In many cases, the connection between the dispute and Delhi was absent, and the pleaded transactions or online activities did not justify invoking its jurisdiction. Therefore, the Court ordered the return of all 17 plaints, allowing their presentation before appropriate courts.
Conclusion
The judgment is an important development in deciding the appropriate forum for IP litigation in India. It supports the difference between genuine commercial activity in a territory and incidental or artificially created connections from online accessibility and isolated purchases.
Authors: Manisha Singh and Shivi Gupta



