Where Copyright Ends, and Personality Rights Begin: The Legal Position on Celebrity Photographs

Where Copyright Ends, and Personality Rights Begin: The Legal Position on Celebrity PhotographsPersonality rights and copyright operate as distinct yet overlapping areas of intellectual property law, particularly in the context of photographs depicting celebrities. While copyright law protects the creative work of the photographer and ordinarily vests ownership in the person who takes the photograph, personality rights seek to protect an individual’s identity, image and commercial persona from unauthorised exploitation. This distinction becomes particularly significant when a photograph is used beyond its original purpose, especially for commercial gain or in a manner suggesting endorsement. The resulting legal question is whether ownership of a photograph also grants the right to commercially exploit the identity captured in it, and where the photographer’s copyright ends and the celebrity’s personality rights begin.

On September 28, 2026, the Delhi High Court raised a question that goes to the root of the personality-rights doctrine. While hearing the suit filed on behalf of Aaradhya Bachchan (CS(COMM) 230/2023), along with two connected suits, Justice Anup Jairam Bhambhani questioned whether a person who is free to photograph the Taj Mahal may be prevented from photographing a celebrity. The Court observed that conventional copyright law vests copyright in a photograph with the photographer and questioned whether the photographer’s subsequent use of that photograph could nevertheless violate the celebrity’s personality rights. The issue prompted the question of whether the photographer must obtain separate clearance of the personality rights of the individual depicted.

The question exposes a fundamental distinction in intellectual property law: ownership of a photograph does not necessarily confer an unrestricted right to commercially exploit the identity of the person depicted in it. Equally, a celebrity’s personality rights do not automatically confer copyright ownership over every photograph in which they appear. Resolving this tension requires a clear understanding of the Copyright Act, 1957, and the legal principles governing personality rights and passing off.

Copyright Ownership and the Person Behind the Photograph

The Copyright Act, 1957, recognises photographs as artistic works under Section 2(c). Section 2(d)(iv) identifies the person taking a photograph as its author, while Section 17 establishes the general rule that the author is the first owner of copyright, subject to statutory exceptions. Accordingly, copyright in a photograph ordinarily belongs to the photographer, rather than the person whose image it captures.

This principle is illustrated by Burrow-Giles Lithographic Co. v. Sarony (1884), in which the United States Supreme Court recognised copyright in a portrait of Oscar Wilde as belonging to the photographer. Indian law similarly attaches authorship to the creation of the photograph, not simply to the identity of the individual depicted.

However, ownership may differ depending on the circumstances in which the photograph was created. A selfie, a commissioned photoshoot, a brand campaign photograph and a photograph taken by a press photographer may attract different ownership rules under Section 17 and the applicable contractual arrangements. Film stills and posters may also involve copyright belonging to a producer or another entitled person.

Consequently, a celebrity cannot claim copyright infringement merely because their photograph has been used without permission. The claimant must establish ownership of, or a legally recognised entitlement to enforce rights in, the particular copyrighted work. As the Delhi High Court held in Time Warner Entertainment Company L.P. v. RPG Netcom (2007), copyright cannot be claimed independently of the statutory framework. Section 16 of the Copyright Act reinforces this position by excluding copyright or similar rights except as provided under the Act or another law in force.

Copyright Ownership Does Not Authorise Every Use

The more difficult question arises when the photographer owns copyright but uses the photograph to commercially exploit the celebrity’s identity.

Section 14 of the Copyright Act confers exclusive rights in the copyrighted work. These rights enable the copyright owner to control specified acts involving that work, subject to the Act’s provisions and limitations. They do not, however, provide immunity from other legal claims that may arise from the manner in which the work is used.

A photograph may therefore involve two distinct legal interests: copyright in the photograph and the legal interests of the person whose identity it depicts. The photographer may own the former without necessarily being entitled to use the latter in every commercial context.

The distinction is particularly significant where a photograph is used in advertising, on merchandise or in a manner that suggests the celebrity has endorsed a product or service. The question is not simply whether the photograph was lawfully obtained or whether the user holds a copyright licence. It is whether the particular use gives rise to an independent legal wrong.

Passing Off: The Link Between Personality Rights and Commercial Goodwill

The principles governing passing off provide an important framework for examining such disputes. In Irvine v. TalkSport Ltd. (2003), a radio station used a photograph of Formula One driver Eddie Irvine in promotional material after substituting a radio for the mobile telephone he was originally holding. Although the station had lawfully purchased the photograph from a photographic agency without infringing copyright, the Court of Appeal upheld liability for passing off because the advertisement conveyed a false impression of endorsement.

Similarly, in Fenty v. Arcadia Group Brands Ltd. (2015), the English Court of Appeal considered the unauthorised use of Rihanna’s photograph on a retailer’s T-shirt. The photograph had been taken by an independent photographer who owned the copyright and licensed its use to the retailer. Nevertheless, the use was capable of amounting to passing off in the circumstances because it conveyed a misleading impression of endorsement.

These decisions demonstrate that copyright ownership and liability for passing off are capable of coexisting. The wrong does not arise merely because a celebrity’s image has been used commercially; it arises where the legally required elements of passing off are established.

In Time Warner, the Delhi High Court identified the traditional requirements of passing off: goodwill or reputation, misrepresentation and resulting damage. The Court also emphasised that a claim based on passing off must be properly pleaded. Similarly, in D.M. Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. v. Baby Gift House (2010), the Court considered whether the unauthorised use of a personality’s identity was likely to mislead consumers into believing that the personality endorsed the product.

More recently, in Digital Collectibles Pte Ltd. v. Galactus Funware Technology Pvt. Ltd. (2023), the Delhi High Court observed that the violation of publicity rights in India must be considered against the principles of passing off and that celebrity identification or commercial gain alone does not establish infringement.

These authorities support a distinction between the commercial appropriation of an identity and a legally actionable misrepresentation. They also raise an important question about the scope of personality-rights claims where no false endorsement, confusion or damage to commercial goodwill has been established.

The Limits of Personality Rights

The recognition of personality rights does not necessarily establish an unrestricted right to control every use of a person’s name, image or likeness. The legal basis and scope of the claim must be examined in the context of the particular use.

The Delhi High Court’s decisions concerning Jaya Bachchan and Khushi Kapoor illustrate the growing judicial engagement with unauthorised commercial exploitation of celebrity identities. However, the ownership of copyright in the underlying photograph is a separate question from the protection available against misuse of personality attributes.

The distinction becomes even more important in the context of photographs taken at public events, editorial reporting, artistic expression and AI-generated imagery. The fact that a person appears in a photograph does not, by itself, determine copyright ownership. Equally, the fact that the photographer owns copyright does not conclusively determine whether a particular use violates another legally protected interest.

A claim must therefore be assessed by identifying the right allegedly infringed, establishing the claimant’s entitlement to enforce that right and examining the nature and consequences of the defendant’s conduct.

Conclusion

The question raised by the Delhi High Court is not simply whether a photographer may take a celebrity’s photograph. It is whether the ownership of that photograph determines the legality of its subsequent use, particularly where the use commercially exploits the identity of the individual depicted.

The Copyright Act 1957 normally puts the copyright in the photographer (subject to the relevant statutory exceptions and any applicable agreements). Personality rights are a separate legal interest and must be considered on their own. Where there is a claim in passing off, the claimant will need to establish the requisite goodwill, the misrepresentation and the damage suffered rather than simply rely on the unauthorised use of a celebrity’s image.

The central point of law is that copyright ownership is not an automatic licence to exploit personality, just as celebrity status is not an automatic basis for claiming copyright. A principled approach requires courts to distinguish the ownership of the photograph from the legal consequences of its use, ensuring that neither copyright nor personality rights become a substitute for establishing the elements of the particular cause of action.

Authors: Manisha Singh and Kratika Patel